The Summer I Turned Pretty’ Review: A Perfectly Distracting YA Romantic Angst Piece of Summer Fluff
Introduction
Prime Video continues its push into young-adult romance with Every Year After, an adaptation of Carley Fortune’s bestselling novel Every Summer After. The series arrives with high expectations, especially among fans of emotional coming-of-age dramas such as The Summer I Turned Pretty and Tell Me Lies.
With a lakeside setting, childhood friendships, first love, heartbreak, and years of emotional baggage, the ingredients seem perfect for another binge-worthy romance. However, while Every Year After delivers plenty of longing looks and emotional moments, it often struggles to make viewers emotionally invest in its central relationship.
The result is a visually appealing but emotionally exhausting series that may divide audiences.
Quick Review Summary
Is Every Year After worth watching?
If you enjoy slow-burn romances, emotional nostalgia, and stories about first love that lasts for years, Every Year After offers enough drama to keep you engaged. However, viewers looking for strong character development, fresh storytelling, and believable romance may find the series repetitive and emotionally draining.
Overall Verdict: Watchable for romance fans, but far from unforgettable.
Movie Overview
Basic Information
- Title: Every Year After
- Platform: Prime Video
- Creators: Amy B. Harris and Leila Gerstein
- Based On: Every Summer After by Carley Fortune
- Genre: Romance, Drama, Coming-of-Age
- Release Date: June 10, 2026
- Episodes: 8
Main Cast
- Sadie Soverall as Percy Fraser
- Matt Cornett as Sam Florek
- Aurora Perrineau as Chantal
- Michael Bradway as Charlie
- Joseph Chiu as Jordy
- Abigail Cowen as Delilah
- Elisha Cuthbert as Sue
Storyline (Spoiler-Free)
At its heart, Every Year After is the story of two childhood best friends whose connection evolves into a complicated romance spanning more than a decade.
Percy Fraser returns to the lakeside Canadian town where she spent her summers growing up after learning about the death of Sue Florek, a woman who was like a second mother to her. Returning home forces Percy to confront memories she has spent years trying to avoid—especially those involving Sam Florek, her childhood friend and former love.
The series alternates between present-day events and flashbacks covering fifteen years of friendship, attraction, misunderstandings, heartbreak, and unresolved feelings.
As Percy and Sam navigate old wounds and lingering emotions, viewers slowly learn what caused their separation and whether they can find a way forward.
The premise is undeniably compelling. Unfortunately, the execution does not always live up to the emotional potential of the story.
Performances
Sadie Soverall as Percy Fraser
Sadie Soverall delivers a committed performance as Percy, portraying a woman burdened by regret and emotional trauma. She captures Percy’s vulnerability effectively, particularly in scenes dealing with grief and anxiety.
However, the character is written in such a melancholy manner that viewers may struggle to connect with her over the course of eight episodes. Percy often appears trapped in the same emotional cycle, limiting the impact of Soverall’s performance.
Matt Cornett as Sam Florek
Matt Cornett brings sincerity and warmth to Sam. He clearly understands the character’s emotional conflict and does his best with the material provided.
Yet Sam never fully develops beyond the archetype of the emotionally unavailable first love. The writing often prevents Cornett from showing greater depth.
Supporting Cast Steals the Spotlight
Ironically, the supporting characters frequently prove more interesting than the leads.
Aurora Perrineau injects energy and realism into Chantal, Percy’s best friend. Her storyline eventually becomes one of the show’s most enjoyable elements.
Joseph Chiu is particularly charming as Jordy, offering a refreshing presence amid the emotional heaviness.
Abigail Cowen also impresses as Delilah, whose personal struggles provide some of the series’ most relatable moments.
Elisha Cuthbert brings warmth and emotional depth to Sue, making her scenes among the most heartfelt in the entire series.
Direction and Screenplay
Strong Concept, Uneven Execution
Creators Amy B. Harris and Leila Gerstein clearly understand the appeal of nostalgic romance. The structure, which moves between past and present timelines, creates mystery and encourages viewers to keep watching.
However, the screenplay repeatedly falls into familiar romance tropes.
The central conflict often feels stretched beyond its natural limits. Instead of allowing characters to grow, the series frequently returns to the same emotional conversations and misunderstandings.
Pacing Problems
One of the biggest issues with Every Year After is pacing.
Eight episodes should provide enough room for meaningful character development. Instead, many scenes revolve around Percy and Sam revisiting identical emotional territory.
Their inability to move forward becomes frustrating rather than heartbreaking.
As a result, viewers may find themselves more invested in secondary storylines than in the central romance.
Emotional Repetition
The series wants viewers to feel the intensity of first love, but it often mistakes repetition for emotional depth.
What begins as romantic longing gradually becomes emotional exhaustion.
Music, Visuals, and Cinematography
Beautiful Lakeside Atmosphere
Visually, Every Year After is one of Prime Video’s stronger romantic dramas.
The Canadian lakeside setting creates a dreamy, nostalgic atmosphere that perfectly suits the story’s themes of memory and lost love.
Cinematography
The cinematography captures both the beauty of summer and the sadness of nostalgia.
Sunlit lakes, quiet docks, evening bonfires, and reflective water shots create postcard-worthy imagery throughout the series.
The visual presentation often succeeds where the screenplay struggles.
Music and Soundtrack
The soundtrack features emotional contemporary artists including:
- Gracie Abrams
- Lana Del Rey
- Noah Cyrus
The music effectively enhances the mood and reinforces the themes of longing and heartbreak.
However, the constant melancholy soundtrack occasionally feels manipulative, pushing viewers to feel emotions that the story itself has not fully earned.
Audience Reaction and Early Reviews
Early reactions have been mixed.
Fans of Carley Fortune’s novel appreciate seeing beloved characters brought to life and enjoy the nostalgic atmosphere.
Romance enthusiasts who favor emotional slow-burn storytelling are likely to find aspects of the series appealing.
However, many critics have highlighted similar concerns:
- Overly repetitive emotional conflicts
- Limited character growth
- Lack of chemistry compared to competing YA romances
- Excessive focus on heartbreak
Some reviewers have even suggested that the show misunderstands what made The Summer I Turned Pretty successful. While that series balanced romance, friendship, family dynamics, and self-discovery, Every Year After often narrows its focus almost entirely to romantic misery.
Box Office Expectations
Since Every Year After is a streaming release, traditional box-office performance does not apply.
Instead, success will be measured through:
- Streaming viewership
- Social media engagement
- Audience retention
- Fan discussions
The series has a strong chance of attracting:
- Fans of Carley Fortune’s novels
- Viewers of The Summer I Turned Pretty
- Young adult romance audiences
- Prime Video subscribers seeking emotional dramas
The built-in fanbase should generate solid initial interest, though long-term popularity will depend on audience word-of-mouth.
What Works Well in the Film
Beautiful Setting
The lakeside backdrop creates a romantic and immersive atmosphere.
Strong Supporting Cast
Several supporting characters are more compelling than the leads and help keep the series engaging.
Effective Nostalgia
The childhood friendship sequences are among the show’s strongest moments.
Emotional Themes
The series explores grief, first love, regret, and personal growth in ways many viewers will relate to.
High Production Quality
Strong cinematography, polished visuals, and an appealing soundtrack elevate the viewing experience.
What Could Have Been Better
Repetitive Romance
The central relationship often feels stuck in an endless cycle of longing and misunderstanding.
Weak Character Development
Percy and Sam do not evolve as much as viewers might expect over the course of eight episodes.
Uneven Pacing
Several episodes feel stretched, reducing emotional impact.
Limited Chemistry
Despite solid performances, the lead pair rarely generates the kind of irresistible chemistry needed for a romance-driven series.
Overreliance on Melodrama
The story frequently chooses emotional suffering over meaningful growth.
Final Verdict
Every Year After has all the ingredients needed for a memorable romantic drama: a beautiful setting, an adored source novel, talented actors, and a compelling premise about first love and second chances.
Unfortunately, the series becomes so focused on heartbreak that it forgets to make viewers fall in love with the romance itself.
There are moments of genuine emotion, particularly in the flashbacks and supporting storylines. The cinematography and atmosphere are consistently impressive, and romance fans may still find enough to enjoy.
Yet for many viewers, the repetitive emotional conflicts and lack of character progression will make the journey feel longer than it needs to be.
Rating: 2.5/5 Stars
Recommended for: Fans of slow-burn romances, emotional dramas, and Carley Fortune’s novel.
Not recommended for: Viewers seeking fresh storytelling, strong romantic chemistry, or fast-paced drama.
#EveryYearAfter #PrimeVideoReview #RomanceDrama #TVSeriesReview #CarleyFortune